How to Make Disney’s Retro Peanut Butter & Jelly Milk Shake at Home

Is there anything better than classic American comfort food? From Grandma’s chicken potpie to a warm apple crisp, it’s hard to say no to nostalgia.

That’s why we were so excited to see Disney has shared yet another amazing recipe from the parks. This time, it’s the Peanut Butter & Jelly Milk Shake from ’50s Prime Time Café in Disney’s Hollywood Studios.

The recipe is simple—it calls for just four ingredients—and it’s definitely kid-approved. Here’s what you need to get started. (Just keep your elbows down!)

How to Make Disney’s Peanut Butter & Jelly Milk Shake

Ingredients:

• 2 tablespoons peanut butter
• 2 cups fresh strawberries or 2 tablespoons jelly (strawberry or grape)
• 2 cups vanilla ice cream
• 1/4 cup milk

Step 1: Prep your ingredients

Start by gathering your ingredients. If you’re using fresh strawberries, wash and remove the stems from each piece of fruit.

Step 2: Add everything to the blender

Next, add all four ingredients to your blender and process until smooth. At this step, grab a spoon and give your shake a sip to make sure it’s to your liking. If desired, you can add more peanut butter and/or jelly to taste.

Step 3: Garnish and serve

Pour your shake in a chilled mug or milk shake glass. Garnish with whipped cream and a cherry, if desired.

Editor’s Tip: Want to take your shake to the next level? Coat the rim of your glass with peanut butter, then dip it in crushed freeze-dried strawberries. Yum!

Still hungry? Disney fans will also love this copycat Dole Whip recipe, the official Disney churro recipe and a bunch of spooky Halloween recipes. While you eat, catch a viewing of the “Happily Ever After” fireworks show or stream one of your favorite films on Disney+.

More Disney Parks Copycat Recipes

1 / 12

Inspired by: Mickey Waffles

A staple both in the parks and at Disney resorts, Mickey waffles are the ultimate morning pick-me-up. Recreate the magic at home with this recipe from No. 2 Pencil. The secret? Using a Mickey Mouse Waffle Maker to imprint that iconic design. Don't forget the powdered sugar! Get Recipe at No. 2 Pencil

Inspired by: Aloha Isle's Dole Whip

On a hot Florida (or California!) day, nothing hits the spot quite like a refreshing Dole Whip. And luckily, this iconic treat is super simple to recreate at home. You just need a few ingredients and a blender—Tiki attire optional. Get Recipe

Inspired by: Turkey Legs

If you haven't walked around the Magic Kingdom while biting into an enormous turkey leg, have you even been to Disney? This recipe features that juicy, smoky flavor you love—and adds a tropical marinade, too.

Get Recipe

Inspired by: Churros

Hold on to your ears because Disney shared its OFFICIAL churro recipe. Yep—this recipe comes straight from the big man, err, mouse, himself. As an added bonus, it's made with pantry staples you likely have on hand.

Get Recipe Want to make some more magic at home? Check out a Disney+ subscription. It has all of your favorite films in one place!

Inspired by: Mickey Beignets

Grab a stack of napkins—you're going to need 'em! This copycat Disney treat from Picky Palate couldn't be simpler. You need just three ingredients. (Plus a Mickey Mouse cookie cutter, of course!) Get Recipe at Picky Palate

Inspired by: Little Red Wagon Corn Dogs

You won't have to wait in line to get one of these bad boys. They're hand-dipped, battered and fried right at home. Pass the mustard, please!

Get Recipe

Inspired by: Be Our Guest French Onion Soup

You're definitely going to want to tie a napkin 'round your neck before tucking into this delicious meal. This soup features the same savory flavors as the one served at the Be Our Guest restaurant.

Get Recipe

Inspired by: Mickey Krispie Treats

Whether you pick one covered in candies, sprinkles or some other sweet topping, Mickey krispie treats are a classic park snack. Magical Treats at Home shows us how to recreate 'em in the comfort of your own kitchen. Get Recipe at Magical Treats at Home

Inspired by: Blue Bayou Monte Cristo

Snagged a coveted reservation at Blue Bayou? Lucky you! For the rest of us, there's this copycat Monte Cristo. The only thing missing is the powdered sugar sprinkle.

Get Recipe

Inspired by: Woody’s Lunch Box S'more French Toast Sandwich

You've got a friend in this French toast. Filled with chocolate and marshmallow—and dipped in graham cracker crumbs—this sweet breakfast is reminiscent of the one found at Woody's Lunch Box.

Get Recipe

Inspired by: Gaston's Tavern Cinnamon Rolls

You're going to need Gaston's appetite to devour one of these fresh-from-the-oven cinnamon rolls. Now if only we had a LeFou's Brew to go with them...

Get Recipe

Inspired by: Funnel Cakes

No trip to a theme park is complete without a funnel cake, and Disney is no exception. This simple recipe will help you create the deep-fried favorite at home—but don't stop there! Go ahead and get creative with your toppings. Whipped cream, fruit, cookies, ice cream—anything is fair game!

Get Recipe

The post How to Make Disney’s Retro Peanut Butter & Jelly Milk Shake at Home appeared first on Taste of Home.

Katie Bandurski